paper mills Smut Clyde

[Citation not needed]

"Even university management eventually realised that self-citations of your work, in your own papers, shouldn't really count ("see 'Toenail Clipping Microphotographs, Part 1', S, Clyde 2018"). So people progressed to citation cabals among cronies, referring to each other's work" - Smut Clyde

Nobody knows how Smut Clyde became obsessed with nanotechnology and materials science, but we do know why he can’t let go of it. This field of research is just too fraudulent. As Smut Clyde reveals here, it’s not just ridiculously fake figures – there are both Chinese papermills and citation cartels in operations, and our allegedly respectable publishes, primarily Elsevier, are eager partners in crime. It’s clear nobody was peer-reviewing or even reading anything, that’s how fake and dumb those advanced materials “studies” are. It’s a strange combination of chickenshit, biofuels and Traditional Chinese Medicine.

Credit: Monty Python

[Citation not needed]

By Smut Clyde

Readers can be excused if the work of C. Zhao and colleagues on foliage waste and biofuels is not central to their interests. It is enough to know that someone is trying out different ways of predigesting leafy agricultural byproducts to break down the lignin and liberate the sugars for fermentation, so we don’t have to. Hydrogen peroxide, ammonia, pre-soaking, composting with chickenshit.

But other scientists do take an interest in this trail that Zhao et al blazed into terra incognita… a remarkable number of people, with eclectic specialities. Theoretical chemistry, petroleum engineering, perovskites, phytopharmacology, surface coatings. Zhao’s papers attract hundreds of citations from a heterogeneous audience, and this is what did pique my interest, indirectly.

  • Hassan, M., Umar, M., Ding, W., Mehryar, E., & Zhao, C. (2017). Methane enhancement through co-digestion of chicken manure and oxidative cleaved wheat straw: Stability performance and kinetic modeling perspectives. Energy, 141, 2314–2320. Cited by 47
  • Qiao, X. L., Zhao, C., Shao, Q. J., Hassan, M., Energy Fuel 2018, 32, 6022-6030. “Structural characterization of corn stover lignin after hydrogen peroxide presoaking prior to ammonia fiber expansion pretreatment” Cited by 121
  • Zhang, M. Q., Zhao, C., Shao, Q. J., Yang, Z. D., Int. J. Agr. Biol. Eng. 2019, 12, 143-148. “Determination of water content in corn stover silage using near-infrared spectroscopy” Cited by 52
  • Zhao, C., Shao, Q. J., Ma, Z. Q., Li, B., Zhao, X. J., Ind. Crop. Prod. 2016, 83, 86-93. “Physical and chemical characterizations of corn stalk resulting from hydrogen peroxide presoaking prior to ammonia fiber expansion pretreatment” Cited by 127
  • Zhao, C., Cao, Y., Ma, Z. Q., Shao, Q. J., Biomass Bioenergy 2017, 98, 61-69. “Optimization of liquid ammonia pretreatment conditions for maximizing sugar release from giant reed (Arundo donax L.).” Cited by 92
  • Zhao, C., Qiao, X. L., Cao, Y., Shao, Q. L., Fuel 2017, 205, 184-191. “Application of hydrogen peroxide presoaking prior to ammonia fiber expansion pretreatment of energy crops” Cited by 149
  • Zhao, C., Qiao, X., Shao, Q., Hassan, M., Ma, Z., 2020a, Evolution of the lignin chemical structure during the bioethanol production process and its inhibition to enzymatic hydrolysis, Energ. Fuel., 2020, 34, 5938-5947. Cited by 103
  • Zhao, C., Qiao, X. L., Shao, Q. J., Hassan, M., Ma, Z. Q., Yao, L. J., Ind. Crop. Prod. 2020, 146, 112177. “Synergistic effect of hydrogen peroxide and ammonia on lignin” Cited by 73

In a series of acts of creative misapprehension, which I choose to label with the deconstructionist term ‘misprision’ because it sounds fancier, a stream of phytopharmacologists convinced themselves that Zhao’s studies were really about processing traditional herbs to maximise the extraction of active ingredients. Twenty-one research teams even independently embedded their bogus citations within identical passages. Another 12 papers in the list used different wording.

Now as a general rule, if the practitioners of Traditional Chinese Medicine insist that composting herbs with chickenshit is an integral processing stage in their healing modality, I happily defer to their expertise. But I would dearly like to know who came up with the idea that preprocessing a toxic arsenical mineral (realgar, α-As4S4) with Zhao-approved treatments would liberate more of the realgar’s active herbal ingredient, which is to say ‘realgar’ (Ma et al 2021).

It is possible that some of these curious citations were simply copy-pasted from earlier papers by authors who didn’t bother reading the source material (probable, even); and that others were inserted by tyrannical reviewers, as a condition of the manuscripts’ acceptance and publication. But could Zhao fan-boys really be gatekeepers for 15 different journals?

“Maximum extraction” is also the general theme of a second group of authors who acknowledged their intellectual debt to Zhao’s seminal studies, for they specialise in ‘oil-well science’ and petroleum technology. The authors understandably make less of an effort to pretend that the references are relevant. Only nine papers (so far), seven of them in Arabian Journal of Geosciences.

Some authors are excluded from the list, for they included the obligatory Zhao references but smuggled them into the text under the rubric of “global energy shortage”, which earns them a special commendation for ingenuity instead.

Moving right along, a third stream of Zhao citations flows from theoretical work, “first-principles studies” and “computational investigations” — software simulations of the electron bands within two-dimensional sheets of graphene-analog materials, and how well those materials will absorb various gaseous molecules. This restricted canon so far consists of 11 papers lacking even vestigial links to organic chemistry. “Adsorption of NO2 on monolayer MoS2 doped with Fe, Co, and Ni, Cu: A first-principles study” is representative of the style, apart from being withdrawn from Results in Physics for unspecified reasons, and republished in Chemical Physics Letters as “Adsorption of NO2 on monolayer MoS2 doped with Fe, Co, and Ni, Cu: A computational investigation“, with entirely different authors.

Papers in this cluster are similar in arrangement and illustrations (which emerge from the same simulation packages), formulaic and template-driven as the authors work systematically through all possible combination of nanosheet substrate + dopant + gas or ion. Evidently a few random references to foliage maceration are part of the template.

“Among the 2D dichalcogenides, MoS2 few-layers have been demonstrated to be promising materials for a large range of applications [20–27].”

  • [20] C. Zhao, et al., Application of hydrogen peroxide presoaking prior to ammonia fiber expansion pretreatment of energy crops, Fuel 205 (2017) 184–191
  • [22] C. Zhao, et al., Evolution of the Lignin Chemical Structure during the Bioethanol Production Process and Its Inhibition to Enzymatic Hydrolysis, Energy & Fuels 34 (5) (2020) 5938–5947.
    • [23] X. Li, Design of novel graphdiyne-based materials with large second-order nonlinear optical properties, J. Mater. Chem. C 6 (28) (2018) 7576–7583.
  • [24] X. Qiao Z. Chao Q. Shao et al. Structural Characterization of Corn Stover Lignin after Hydrogen Peroxide Presoaking Prior to Ammonia Fiber Expansion Pretreatment[J] Energy & Fuels acs 2018 energyfuels. 8b00951.
  • [25] Chao Z, Yan C, Ma Z, et al. Optimization of liquid ammonia pretreatment conditions for maximizing sugar release from giant reed (Arundo donax L.)[J]. Biomass & Bioenergy, 2017, 98(2):61-69.
  • [26] Z. Chao, Q. Shao, Z. Ma, et al., Physical and chemical characterizations of corn stalk resulting from hydrogen peroxide presoaking prior to ammonia fiber expansion pretreatment[J], Ind. Crops Prod. 83 (2) (2016) 86–93.
  • [27] C. Zhao, X. Qiao, Y. Cao, et al., Application of hydrogen peroxide presoaking prior to ammonia fiber expansion pretreatment of energy crops[J], Fuel 205 (2017) 184–191.

For variety, these are mingled with other absurdly irrelevant citations:

Especially the monolithic molybdenum disulfide has a large specific surface area and a large edge unsaturated bond which provides abundant active sites and adsorption sites [16–19].

  • [16] C. Zhao, et al., Synergistic effect of hydrogen peroxide and ammonia on lignin, Ind. Crops Prod. 146 (4) (2020) 112177.
  • [19] Q. Wan, Y. Zhang, R. Zhang, Using mechanical activation of quartz to enhance the compressive strength of metakaolin based geopolymers, Cem. Concr. Compos. 103635 (2020).

… monolayer MoS2 has superior electronic properties and has been widely concerned in transistor fabrication and electron probe applications [6–15]“.

  • [8] C.C. Shen, M.M.A. Green, O.O. Breitenstein, et al., Solar energy materials and solar cells, North-Holland, 1992.
  • [9] R.H. Kim, S. Kim, Y.M. Song, et al., Flexible vertical light emitting diodes, Small 8 (20) (2012) 3123–3128.
  • [13] Z. Liu, J. Yang, F. Grey, et al., Observation of microscale superlubricity in graphite [J], Phys. Rev. Lett. 108 (20) (2012) 205503.
  • [14] J. Ni, W. Wang, M. Quintana, F. Jia, S. Song, Adsorption of small gas molecules on strained monolayer WSe2 doped with Pd, Ag, Au, and Pt: A computational investigation, Appl. Surf. Sci. 514 (2020) 145911,
  • [15] N. Jiaming Q. Mildred S. Shaoxian Adsorption of small gas molecules on transition metal (Fe, Ni and Co, Cu) doped graphene: A systematic DFT study [J] Physical E 2020 113768(116).

What is going on here? All is clarified by a contribution to a PubPeer comment thread, by “Oriensubulitermes inanis“:

step 1: you need to find an agent, who has and manages a pool of papers, you should pay the fee and put your papers in the pool.
step 2: in the future when you have a manuscript, you shall tell the agent about the title and the keywords, the agent would then tell you to cite some papers in the pool, and this is what you see here, these papers are not related to the topic but belong to a more broad topic like “materials science” “catalyst” etc, and it makes sense. The agents are not scholars, they are running a business.
step 3: after you have done this, in the future, your own paper would be cited by the other groups of authors in their papers. Since your papers are in the pool, the agent would request other groups in the pool to cite them as an exchange.
step 4: the agents would give you word that how many citations to your paper would be granted in a specific time frame, for example, in the next year 30 citations.

As predicted by Goodhart’s Law, no end of ingenuity has gone into ways of working the metric of citation indices, and this is the latest development. Readers are all aware by now that citations are how university administrators distinguish between staff who are doing valuable research, and those who are merely publishing inconsequential microphotographs of their toenail clippings. Citations bring promotion, and funding, or at least continued employment.

Even university management eventually realised that self-citations of your work, in your own papers, shouldn’t really count (“see ‘Toenail Clipping Microphotographs, Part 1’, S, Clyde 2018”). So people progressed to citation cabals among cronies, referring to each other’s work — “You scratch my log and I’ll roll your back”, or perhaps vice versa — until advances in citation-graph mining made those more detectable in turn.

Oriensubulitermes inanis is describing a more diffuse form of citation network, where no member needs to know any other members, and the beauty of it is the lack of tell-tale reciprocal links in the citation graph. Researchers in the network undertake to cite other members’ papers from the pool, in return for their own papers going into the pool to be cited by other, different members.

Of course citation manipulation networks don’t organise themselves; a broker spots candidates and invites them to join (for a small fee to cover administration). Some might regard this behaviour as the scholarly equivalent of Performance-Enhancing Drugs, but I prefer to think of it as a type of collective action, a kind of academic union. Solidarity, brothers and sisters!

O. inanis concludes:

“Finally, you will see that this is a carefully designed, un-trackable network. The agent gets the entrance fee to the paper pool from the scholars, the scholars get the reward of citations and the bonus, the research community and the institution get high due to the more highly cited papers, and the journals can also be benefited from the higher impact factor.”

The hallmark of a network would be a heterogeneous co-citing cluster — a cluster of papers brought together by their citational proximity (i.e. they refer to the same papers) although they have little else in common. But now I seem to have given away the twist ending. Writing scripts for M. Night Shyamalan movies is not for me!

And we haven’t even touched on all the sources of Zhao-related citations! It has been a while since the last blatantly-fraudulent electron-microscopy images, so here is some weapons-grade photoshoppery from “Magnetic properties and thermal stability of SrFe12O19/γ-Fe4N composites with effective magnetic exchange coupling” (Zhang, 2020):

Zhang (2020) comes from a worksheet of 40-odd papers in the nanotech / advanced-materials field, mostly published in Ceramics International, in which “citation here” slots in the text have been filled with papers from a familiar list… anti-corrosion coatings, bacterial and photocatalytic breakdown of industrial pollutants, persulphates, Fenton reactions, and of course biofuels. Over half of these feature results that were derived from the digital domain, rather than from reality. And authors were not independently resorting to Appearance-Enhancing Software to compensate for their lack of advanced-synthesis and electron-microscope facilities, for images in otherwise-unrelated papers turn out to be assembled from the same components. and the same style shines through them all. Here,

Fig 1(a) from “Synthesis of functional hollow WS2 particles with large surface area for Near-Infrared (NIR) triggered drug delivery” (Liu et al 2021), “The characterization results for the as-synthesized WS2 hollow particles”.
Figs 1a,d from “Anchoring single Pt atoms on hollow Ag3VO4 spheres for improved activity towards photocatalytic H2 evolution reaction” (Ma et al 2021), “TEM (inset: SEM for a broken hollow particle).. for AVO particles; … TEM… AVO/Pt-3 composite particles”.

[left] Fig 10a of “Constructing magnetically recoverable CdS/CaFe2O4 P–N heterojunctions for enhanced photoelectrochemical properties towards H2 evolution reaction” (Cao et al 2021), “TEM image of CS/CFO-2 after six reaction cycles”
[right] Fig 1h from “CdS nanoparticles decorated Ag2WO4 nanorods for increased photocatalytic performance and stability under visible light irradiation” (Jing & Kang 2020), “TEM … of Ag2WO4/CdS-3 composite.”

Three of the authors from Cao et al had previously signed “Atomic layer deposition of Cu2O on NH2-MIL-101(Fe) for enhanced photocatalytic performance and decreased electron/hole recombination” (Geng et al 2021), which contains the assemblage known as Fig 1(c):

I could go on for there is enough material here for a whole post. If all the fake images come from a single source, it is probably also the source of the text. Unusually for a papermill, the clients are not just medical clinicians, but also engineering and physics staff from polytechnics and provincial universities, relying repeatedly on the millers’ services to keep their research funds flowing.

Figs 1(d) and 7(d) from “Wet chemistry synthesis of CuFe2O4/CdSe heterojunction for enhanced efficient photocatalytic H2 evolution under visible irradiation” (Li et al 2021).
Figs 1(a) and (d) from “Loading Rh single atoms onto hollow cubic Cu2MoS4 nanoparticles for decreased electron/hole recombination and increased photocatalytic performance” (Wei et al 2022)

Figs 1(a), 1(d) of “Synthesis of hollow structured Bi4O5Br2/Cu2O P–N heterojunctions with large surface area for enhanced photocatalytic performance towards the degradation of organic dyes” (Liu et al 2021).

Anyway, this papermill provides its customers with higher-profile publications by plugging into a citation-manipulation network… the same one that elsewhere turns out to be working with the ‘Crystallography papermill‘.

Fig 1(a), and References, from “The application of hierarchy MoS2 particles for NIR induced drug delivery towards liver cancer treatment” (Wang et al 2020).

If it weren’t for the resulting bogus References, I don’t know if its products would have been flagged at PubPeer. Of course the links between papermilling and citation manipulation lead both ways: Zhao’s biofuel canon is attracting attention because of the recurring chickenshit references in the crystallography papermill’s output (all embedded within a much larger citation economy).

Let me boast, in conclusion, that I was reading Zhao’s pre-processing papers while they were still known only to agricultural-bycatch-to-biofuels hipsters, before the authors sold out and started pandering to a broader audience.

But now I feel guilty about depriving the readers of other modalities of Figure fabrication, so here are some current / time graphs from “Electrochemical Sensor Based on Silver Nanoparticles/Multi‐walled Carbon Nanotubes Modified Glassy Carbon Electrode to Detect Cyanide in Food Products” (Zhang 2020): Figures 5a/b, and 6a.

That paper belongs to a compilation of citation-payload papers from the Journal of Electrochemical Science. Their payloads of spurious citations do not include C. Zhao’s biofuel canon but many other old friends are there. That worksheet is very much a work-in-progress, for J. Electrochem Sci must have a policy of welcoming contributions from manipulation networks, and it is absolutely riddled with problematic papers; and for the same reason, I do not know if it will progress much further.

Yet another manifestation of the manipulation-network phenomenon is the Jun Zhao / Zhiqin Zheng corpus of 14 papers,  focussed on advanced materials, broadly but not exclusively on perovskites. I have written about their output already. As with a scorpion, the tail is the part that demands attention, and in a Zhao/Zheng paper the payload of citation is contained in the few final sentences (inserted as corrections at the proof-reading stage, and not seen by the journal’s reviewers).

If there were any vestigial element of rationality in the workings of academic administration, all this would convince the management to admit that their reliance on the metric of citations indices was all a dreadful mistake. Meanwhile the agencies that calculate those indices would recalculate everything to correct for cheating. I am not holding my breath.

Donate to Smut Clyde!

If you liked Smut Clyde’s work, you can leave here a small tip of 10 NZD (USD 7). Or several of small tips, just increase the amount as you like (2x=NZD 20; 5x=NZD 50). Your donation will go straight to Smut Clyde’s beer fund


4 comments on “[Citation not needed]

  1. I am wondering, is there a third party setting up those citation rings or are the authors casually meeting like in a mafia movie to discuss the yearly plans?


    • smut.clyde

      According to the testimony of “Oriensubulitermes inanis“ there are outside organisers, who contact prospective members. “Hi, it looks like you’re publishing a lot to get promoted, but your papers need to be cited more.” [imagine a Clippy voice]. The new members pay a levy. They receive lists of papers that they should cite in their next manuscript; in exchange for their own papers being cited by other authors.


  2. smut.clyde

    ‘Parashorea tomentella’ Pubpeerified a few papers from “Applied Ecology and Environmental Research” (a low-profile Hungarian journal). They’re good examples of the style. At least two are plagiarised (but with extra citations).








  3. Pingback: A rule-based structure of three pigs – For Better Science

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: